Last week we gave an overview of our proposal for downtown Salisbury. Once thing we noted is that there are NO silver bullets. Doing just one or two things is not going to revive Salisbury’s downtown. However, if there is any one thing that comes close to being a silver bullet it is - WHO DO WE MARKET DOWNTOWN TO.
Two Parts to a Single Question
There are two parts to this question:
- Who do we market to regarding investment?
- Who do we market to as consumers?
Downtown has been compared to a ghost town. That’s not wholly inaccurate. At 5 o’clock the proverbial streets are rolled up. There is plenty of office space. There is plenty of residential space. There simply isn’t much retail space and no compelling reason to come downtown even if there was.
We need investors who are willing to take a long term view and who are creative enough to develop businesses that people want to come downtown to visit and patronize. Such businesses will act as anchors that then encourage people to visit other businesses in the same general area.
Obviously, no business, no matter how unique or interesting, will succeed without paying customers. We need to identify those customers and market to them.
Yuppies and Students
Let’s reverse things for a moment. We’ll discuss the potential investors in a bit. For now, let’s look at who we should market to as potential consumers.
Salisbury is a college town. I realize that many citizens want to treat Salisbury University as the red-headed step child, but the fact remains that SU is one of the three or four primary drivers of our local economy (SU, PRMC, Perdue, other Agri-Business).
College students are a ready made market for downtown. They simply need a reason to come down there. Transportation shouldn’t be an issue. I’m willing to bet that SU would add downtown to its own bus route for students that can’t (or don’t want to) drive.
We here a lot about “young professionals”. This is a key market as well. Once people start having families, going out isn’t something that can be done often, or on a regular basis. When you get old, like me, going out often just isn’t something that you do that often either. Sure, you go out to eat, but you don’t go out for three or four hours a night multiple times a week.
We don’t need another bar! That is the response you get from many people. I would disagree. Bars are not de facto bad things. I would also argue that you need MORE than a bar or two to attract AND RETAIN a steady stream of college students and people under 30. You need some kind of destination – a reason to come downtown IN ADDITION TO a couple of bars and a few restaurants.
The Gay Community
That’s right. I said it. The GAY community! Now I’m not talking about the gay community as a primary market – although this particular demographic would certainly fit many of the criteria that make college students and people (in general) under 30 a prize market. No – I’m talking about marketing to the gay community as your investor class.
The gay community has a long and successful history of being urban pioneers. They tend to have access to capital, a higher than average disposable income, and don’t have the financial responsibility of raising a family unless they choose to adopt or go the surrogacy route. Let’s face it; if you’re gay, there are no unplanned pregnancies.
Look around. Many of the people responsible for the re-birth of Cape Charles, VA (hardly San Francisco East) are gay. Go to the Ghent section of Norfolk. Now a thriving part of the city, Ghent as a slum when I was a kid. What changed? A small group of gay urban pioneers who were willing to put their capital at risk and then worked hard to make their dreams a reality. There are countless examples all across the country.
I am not proposing that we attempt to turn Salisbury’s downtown into the Castro. My experience has been that our friends and neighbors are pretty much the rest of us. They just happen to make different sleeping arrangements. They don’t flout their sexual orientation and simply expect to be treated as you would treat anyone else.
That said, gays are a distinct demographic group. Some of the things that I’ve mentioned above make them ideal candidates to lead the revitaliztion of Salisbury’s downtown.
If we were serious about promoting Salisbury, we’d be doing in the Washington Blade and Philadelphia Gay News.
G. A. Harrison is the Managing Editor of “Salisbury News”. Delmarva Dealings appears each Wednesday and Sunday at SbyNEWS.com.
22 comments:
College students will have no reason to come to the hole that is downtown once the new shops open up beneath the new dorms on 13. With the selection of restaurants already there, access to banks and other services there is just no reason. Any businessman that would be interested in your plan is going to realize that the plaza is simply an uphill battle compared to a prime location by campus if that is going to be his target audience.
And seriously the gay community? Last I saw they make up somewhere between 6 and 15% of the national population despite being all over tv and the news. You really think they are going to support a thriving economy by themselves? Besides they already have Rehobeth. Why would they need to start over from scratch.
I think to revitalize this area, we need to do a few things.
First.... parking. More of it, and get rid of those obnoxious parking meters.
Take some of the property there and turn it into "sheik" housing locations... much like was done on S. Patterson Park Ave in Baltimore outside of Patterson Park.
Along with the "sheik" housing there needs to be some sort of incentive for businesses to open in this area.. certainly more restaurants/bars venues for live music, but also niche craft/artsy type stores. Oh, and a Starbucks. Nothing says trendy credibility like a Starbucks... and no, I'm not being sarcastic or cheeky. Possibly incentivise businesses by offering better tax breaks for opening in this area?
If we could make it seem like an equivalent to a "Fells Point" or a "Canton" like Baltimore has... people WILL move there, AND college kids will patronize the area.
Dunno if this is what you had in mind... but my simple 2 cents.
It all stems from the parking. Until the city stops charging to park downtown, there will be no businesses.
Rent on the plaza is very cheap. Until the parking situation gets figured out, there is no point in trying.
Anon 1220 -
You missed the point! I specifically stated that the primary purpose of marketing to the gay community was because they would be the entrepreneurial / investor class that would develop downtown. Yes, they would be part of the consumer market as well.
As for college kids, they would come downtown IF there was something to draw them. That is why you need investors who are creative enough to build a business that is a destination rather than merely a shop. By doing that, people come downtown to the DESTINATION and then begin exploring around and patronizing the other businesses.
This is how it works everywhere that I've seen it done.
*****************************
Conservative Atheist -
Good points all. In fact, I'll be discussing many of these in later pieces. Over the next several weeks I'll devote each Wednesday column to my "Proposal for Downtown Salisbury". Then I'll try to sum it up.
While I have an overall outline, I am still researching components of the proposal and interviewing various downtown business owners, government folks, and community leaders.
If you don't mind, I might even steal some of your ideas.
@ G.A.
I don't mind at all... it benefits all of us to have a booming downtown Salisbury! I look forward to your upcoming Wednesday articles!
Clean up the RIVER!!!!!!! That is the draw for downtown. That river is a Sh*t hole....literally.
anonymous 1:36, Are you Jim Ireton, because that's a load of crap. Cleaning up the river will NOT in itself revitalize Downtown.
I must add a negative to this situation unfortunately...The riff-raff issue currently being generated by the under 21 club. Many people, myself included, would never even consider investing while the unruley crowd is present, which brings us to another point, What do we do to get that under control. Obviously, law enforcement would need to be involved, but then that detracts from their duties in other parts of the city. Most of the issues are NOT caused by SU students, but rather by "thugs" coming from near by communities. Am I saying close down the under 21 club? No, but THE OWNERS need to step up and stop letting the drunk and high people enter their premises. Many that patronize that business arrive already "buzzed". College stundents do not want to hang around that type of atmosphere and nor would I. Just my 2 cents....
I've seen the same situation in several towns and small cities. In most cases, the towns/cities at some point realize that things are NEVER AGAIN going to be as they once were. Once this happens they move forward and make the most of what they have. Salisbury is the county seat and the "crossroads of the eastern shore". Make the most of it and develop office space for lawyers, accountants, bankers, investment firms etc. Apartments for young professionals in the upper floors.When this happens, you will have a need/desire for lunch shops, a barber, hair dresser, perhaps a small stationary store, s few specialty craft stores, and even a pub or two. It has been a winning combo for several downtown areas.
Someone go to Charlottesville, Va and see how the University of Virginia simply took over the town as the college grew.
We've been talking about this for 10 years.... its the same solutions over and over again that Salisbury refuses to act on. It's not rocket surgery.
Unless the good ole boys sign onto the plan, nothing will happen, and I doubt anything ever will happen.
Anon 1343 -
This is most definitely one solution. In fact, I was discussing this with several business owners yesterday. However, I do not think that Salisbury needs to do this nor should they.
Basically you are arguing for the "heads and beds" view. This is definitely an option. However, I do believe that you can develop downtown into a destination. We have enough population density.
However, if the city and community leaders cannot agree on a LONG TERM plan and a funding stream, then we should opt for your proposal.
***********************
Anon 1411 -
I disagree that the University has taken over the Hook. Granted, the University has expanded, but it is mostly west and NW. Check out C-ville's Downtown Plaza. It was recently renovated and has come a LONG way since I was a student.
just what you need. more bars, tattoo parlors and the like, down town with the library and children seeing the mess. no, you statemnts are simply impratical. it needs to be bull dozed down, and returned to a place where mature people can connduct retail or other business. don't bring the bad element of college students to downtown. we have a couple houses now in our neighborhood, high clas neighborhood, being brought down by these drunken bums that call themselves college studetns. put a fence around the college, and charge admission to watch them act like the fools they are.
unfortunately, we get to see it free here. fence them in, i'd pay to see the idiots, more entertaining than the shorebirds.
Outlets,plain and simple.LL Bean,Lands End Nike etc,etc.The City parking lot would be adequate.If 2 or 3 succeeded,more would come
Anon 1535 -
Really? First of all, I never said boo about tattoo parlors. Second, I'm not talking about dive bars. Third, I can't believe you really believe that about SU.
Would you prefer that SU just go away? Would you like to see your taxes doubled or tripled (or more) because all that economic activity simply went away?
Have a problem with a particular student? Call the cops. Call the University. Call their landlord. Just don't try to put every SU student into the same basket as your problem children.
I have a huge solution for Salisbury: Get rid of your big lard butt and move Joe back to jail where he belongs. That is an instant improvement to the community!
3:41 has a good suggestion. If we could get shops such as those in the outlets and then pubs and other kinds of eating establishments, we might begin to move toward a viable downtown.
We want more parking, but free parking, and the city can't spend any of our taxpayer money, and we gotta give incentives to business, but oh yeah without spending any money. Does this all sound ludicrous to anyone else? If you are actually willing to go to shops and nice restaurants but its that $2 in the meter that ruins it, well then i just dont understand you. Whoever said make it more like fells point or canton, those are vastly residential areas with tons of foot traffic and populations to support the commerce. And no, the two buildings of apartments in the plaza don't provide enough foot traffic to keep a hot dog cart open.
9:40 PM
I thought they were looking for suggestions, not criticism.
We have enough problems, we need solutions.
Sorry 10:16 I meant no criticism, only to point out the useless suggestions of some posters. The city should build more parking, and give huge incentives to businesses, yet how dare they spend money or charge for parking. Downtown can only thrive by becoming a tourist destination and/or having a large central population to cater to. It is neither.
Who keep bring all the syringes downtown, condoms on the ground and plastic bagges? Must be the elderly? Parking for FREE, never heard of it, someone is going to pay even if it appears FREE. Most city build the so called FREE parking into some form of tax that gets passed along to the patron in higher product and service prices or to the owners and renters in form of a taz or in the rent. Who do you think pays for the mall secuirty and the lot re-pavements and up keep? Don't kid yourself. The answer is more types of businesses people want to visit and then they don't mind paying a few extra quarters for parking or they will use the 2 hr FREE lot and feel they got a bargin.
I am 58 years old,so I can recall the downtown glory days.I don't want to rain on anyones picnic,but the old business concept can never be regained.Retail businesses must be miniturized to survive,such as outlets offer.What a terrific location!Rt 50 would provide access,as would 13.People would no longer have to travel to get to their favorite outlets.
Post a Comment