Attention

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not represent our advertisers

Friday, July 17, 2015

The Lidar Lie

After Baltimore City's disastrous speed camera program was forced to admit that their supposedly perfectly calibrated equipment had produced erroneous speed camera tickets due to what speed camera contractor Xerox referred to as "radar effects", speed camera using agencies desperately needed to find a new narrative to replace the platitude "if you won't speed you won't get a ticket".

One of the claims now made is that even though there were problems with speed cameras in Baltimore, that other speed cameras which measure speed with LIDAR cannot be wrong. The implication that the device uses laayyyzeerrrs, which sound spacey and high tech, is supposed to lead one to believe the device cannot be wrong.

Of course, this is not true. It has been known for years that even devices which are properly calibrated, which theoretically include "error correcting" software, can still be wrong. One mechanism of error is the sweep effect, something which has been known to exist and documented for years.

More
 

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

here's a question i have. let's say there's a speed camera on a 3-lane highway (Rt. 50 business right in front of Wi Middle School). and let's say there is one vehicle in each lane traveling in the same direction. one car is traveling the speed limit (35 mph). one car is going 55 mph. and the last car is going 80 mph. they all reach the "snap shot" spot at the same time. how in the heck can they tell which car triggered the camera, and who gets the ticket? i've always wondered that.

Anonymous said...

They can't and most people just pay the fine. You are supposed to be able to legally face your accuser in court. Tell me where that went? Out the window for the sake of greed. Speed cameras are not right they morally are wrong and should be illegal.