I believe this request (attached) was actually a very simple one, and that it is nowhere near as difficult as Brekford's representative is suggesting. Annual calibration certificates and daily setup logs for Speed Monitoring Systems are required by state law transportation article 21-809 to be "kept on file" and to be provided as evidence in court hearings. These documents are the only proof a motorist or the court has that the devices are properly calibrated and maintained. Furthermore since Salisbury operates the cameras and the operator is required to sign the logs, I'm confused as to why you would not have these documents readily available.
My understanding of the intent of state law was that by requiring these documents to be 'on file' means they are to be made available to anyone at any time for any reason. I do not believe there is any dispute as to whether such documents are disclosable under the MPIA, since other jurisdictions have disclosed them. The SHA now posts their annual calibration certificates to their website. It should not require a prolonged legal examination to release them..
The third item in my request (a technical specification) is usually simply marketing material or part of training/operating materials I would reasonably expect you to have on hand since Salisbury 'operates' the devices. In any event the other items should not be delayed even if you do not have such a document.
This really was not intended to be a complicated information request. There have been issues with Brekford speed camera calibrations in other jurisdictions such as Hagerstown and Greenbelt. If your contractor is continuing to delay this request after the maximum period state law allows to provide a response, perhaps Salisbury should confirm that Brekford does not have some reason for not providing the documents other than simply being too busy.
Thank you for your valuable time and assistance on this matter. I do appreciate that you are attempting to satisfy the request, and I look forward to receiving Salisbury's response containing all requested documents.
--Ron Ely
699 West Salisbury Parkway
Salisbury, MD 21801
Cc: spdchief@salisburypd.comknichols@ci.salisbury.md.us
jpick@ci.salisbury.md.us
MARYLAND PUBLIC INFORMATION ACT REQUEST
Pursuant to the Maryland Public Information Act, State Government Article §§10-611 through §§10-630, I am requesting copies of the following records in the custody of Salisbury or contractors keeping them on your behalf:
The annual calibration certificates for ALL speed monitoring systems used by Salisbury during any portion of 2011, 2012, or 2013.
The daily setup/deployment logs for all speed cameras used in Salisbury on the following dates:
October 19, 2012
November 1, 2012
December3, 2012
January 3, 2013
February 1, 2013
The technical specifications of speed cameras used in Salisbury.
I previously sent this by email on June 5 and am following up with a mailed request.
I request that fees be waived for this request since the release of these records is in the public interest, as they are highly relevant to matters in the public discourse and including matters of recently considered state legislation. The principal embodied of the text of the MPIA that "All persons are entitled to have access to information about the affairs of government and the official acts of public officials and employees" demands a high level of transparency by local speed camera programs.
If providing scanned electronic copies of these documents is possible, then I would prefer that they be provided in that form and sent to this email address: StopBigBrotherMD@gmail.com.
If any privilege is claimed under the law to deny any portion of this request, then I request that all non-privileged portions of requested records be provided. Since state law specifies that daily setup logs and annual calibration certificates be kept “on file”, then I believe those records should rightly be released immediately regardless of whether there might be time required for other portions of this request.
I look forward to your response at the earliest possible time, and within 30 days in any event. Thank you for your time and attention.
Sincerely,
Ronald Ely
Maryland Drivers Alliance11817 Silent Valley Lane
North Potomac, MD 20878
StopBigBrotherMD@gmail.com
Sounds like my speeding ticket will be voided!
ReplyDeleteFrom WBOC's article, "Chief Duncan also added that the cameras are calibrated twice a day as well as an annual calibration as required by Maryland state law."
ReplyDeleteSeems to me if they have time to do this twice a day, they have time to email Mr. Ely the results twice a day.
But, it takes time to "compile" the requested information?????
I smell a "pile".
If they have missed the response deadline it's time to request a circuit court hearing. The gentleman will certainly win because the law is crystal clear about responding. The department has already violated the law by not responding in the proper time frame.
ReplyDeleteHow are these camera's calibrated?
ReplyDeleteare they "Smart" camera's in that they can be polled and calibrated remotely? (like that of electric and water meters)
just asking...
Did'nt this all begin because of people driving too fast in school zones? Were'nt the cameras initially intended to keep school kids safe walking to and from school?
ReplyDeleteSince school is out and there are no kids to keep safe right now, why are the cameras still rolling. Another lie from downtown??!!?? We knew anyway it was all about money, nothing more.
ReplyDeleteHow is the camera on South Division a school zone. I don't think that college housing counts as a school zone.
ReplyDeleteI noticed the cameras on College Ave have been moved, closer together. It seems the area of coverage is smaller??
ReplyDeleteThe post is about freedom of information request, not the camera.
ReplyDelete